In a brazen and disheartening crime that strikes at the heart of a small business and the spirit of the season, a family-owned nursery in Northeast Ohio was ruthlessly targeted by thieves who made off with roughly 200 Christmas trees in a single, calculated heist. The Smith Evergreen Nursery, a local institution, was left reeling after staff arrived on the morning of Monday, November 24th, to discover that a massive quantity of their prepared inventory had vanished without a trace over the preceding weekend, an act that has left the owners feeling personally violated during what should be their most prosperous and joyful time of year.
The sheer scale and audacity of the theft is staggering. The criminals did not merely grab a few trees from the edge of the property; they executed a systematic operation. According to owner Ian Smith, who spoke with News 5 Cleveland, the thieves cleaned out an entire load of cut-and-bundled trees, primarily consisting of premium 7- to 9-foot Fraser firs, from a loaded truck and the surrounding yard. In a detail that underscores the thieves’ cold efficiency, they even moved the vehicle itself and took its key, suggesting a level of planning far beyond a random act of vandalism. This was a professional-grade robbery aimed squarely at a family’s livelihood.
The financial impact of this crime is severe and deeply personal for the Smith family. They estimate the direct wholesale loss at between $8,000 and $10,000, a significant sum for any small business. When considering the retail value those trees would have commanded for the family or the garden centers they supply, the loss could potentially double, making this not just an inventory hit but a devastating blow to their annual revenue. The emotional toll was palpable in Ian Smith’s words to reporters, as he stated, “It makes you sick,” adding, “It hurts. It’s hard not to take it personally.” This sentiment reflects the vulnerability of hard-working Americans who play by the rules, only to be victimized by those who utterly disregard them.
The local authorities, specifically the Carroll County Sheriff’s Office, have confirmed the unusual nature of this crime. Deputy Erik Licht, who is investigating the case, noted that such a theft is an anomaly in the largely rural community. He told News 5 Cleveland, “Usually, it’s ATVs. Side-by-sides. Chainsaws. Things like that get stolen. This is the first time I’ve ever taken a report for cut pine trees.” His statement highlights the premeditated and specific nature of this heist, distinguishing it from common property crimes. Deputy Licht did indicate that there are potential leads in the case and has made a public appeal for information, urging anyone with knowledge to contact the sheriff’s office.
In the frustrating aftermath, it was revealed that the family’s security cameras, meant to deter such crimes, failed to capture the incident due to blind spots, a lapse the family has now moved to correct by repositioning the equipment. The immediate consequence of the theft was a frantic scramble by nursery employees to mitigate the damage. They were forced to work overtime to cut fresh trees in order to fulfill critical pre-Thanksgiving orders for various clients, including local garden centers, a church, and even a Boy Scout troop in Cincinnati, demonstrating how this single criminal act created a ripple effect of hardship and inconvenience for the broader community.
Watch
A separate report from the Canton Repository provided additional context, placing the number of stolen trees closer to 150 and citing owner Ian Smith’s estimate of an average wholesale value of $65 per tree. Using these figures, the financial devastation remains profound. The family, determined to recover their property and see justice served, has taken the step of offering a $500 reward for information leading to the resolution of the case.
This theft is more than a statistic; it is a direct attack on the American dream of family enterprise and a grim reminder of the lawlessness that can impact even the most peaceful of communities, forcing hard-working citizens to invest in security rather than growth.