Massachusetts Island Residents Stunned by Letter Targeting American Flags
Residents on Plum Island in Massachusetts say a letter from the town of Newbury left them confused and angry. The notice warned that certain items placed near beach and dune areas could run afoul of state and federal wildlife rules.
The letter said officials had become aware of devices and materials intended to deter protected shorebirds from using those areas. It listed “mylar streamers, flags, and reflective materials.” The town also warned that activities seen as harassment or disruption of normal feeding, nesting, or migratory behavior can bring “significant regulatory and financial penalties.”
That is where the backlash started. Some homeowners say they were stunned to see American flags included in the warning, especially with the nation’s 250th birthday approaching. Marc Sarkady, who has lived on the island for more than 30 years, said, “Are you serious?!” He added, “You’re telling me I can’t fly American flags on my property to celebrate America 250?”
Sarkady also argued that the island has plenty of open space for birds. He pointed to “10 miles of open beach” where the wildlife can still move freely. Before the letter arrived, he and other residents had already been gearing up for a big July 4 celebration. They handed out about 50 American flags and about 100 signs that read, “Plum Island Honors America.”
“It’s really us trying to bring the island together — everybody, by the way, not left, not right, America, American citizens, and really reaching out. That’s really the spirit of what I’m trying to do here,” Sarkady said.
Town officials say they are not banning patriotic displays. Newbury Town Administrator Tracy Blais said the town agreed to MassWildlife’s request to help “spread the word” about protecting endangered species. Still, many residents say the wording of the letter tells a different story.
Sarkady also said a Massachusetts Division of Fisheries and Wildlife official sent a similar warning last year to one of his neighbors after she put up ornamental banners on her beachside lawn. He said the language matched the newer letter closely, and that the official later called the neighbor directly and warned of serious penalties if she did not comply.