Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis answered Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed’s Thomas Jefferson Quran reference by pointing to a darker chapter of American diplomatic history. El-Sayed had mentioned Jefferson’s ownership of the religious text while discussing his likely choice for taking the oath of office. DeSantis responded with an account of Jefferson and John Adams questioning the Tripoli ambassador about attacks on other nations. His intervention shifted the argument from owning a book to confronting rulers who invoked religion to justify violence. That is relevant context, though it does not establish why Jefferson originally bought his copy.
El-Sayed’s remarks came during an interview with NPR’s Leila Fadel, who said he had “faced a really ugly campaign … that really leaned on bigoted tropes about your ethnicity, your religion, and that started at the top.” Asked about his religion, El-Sayed discussed the book he might use for his oath. “I will likely swear on the Quran, which Quran, we’re not sure. I mean Thomas Jefferson had a copy of the Quran… I’ll swear on a Quran.” His answer identified a likely choice, not a particular edition. The Jefferson reference became the flashpoint.
The Thomas Jefferson Quran Reference Meets a Historical Challenge
The immediate dispute centered on what Jefferson’s ownership actually meant. An X user posting as Vanessa asked whether El-Sayed knew why Jefferson had a Quran. Another user, Simon Bar Sinister, answered that Jefferson was an educated man. Twitchy reported that historians pointed to Jefferson purchasing a two-volume English translation in 1765 while studying law in Williamsburg, Virginia. That purchase establishes possession and provides historical context. It does not, by itself, settle the larger argument over Jefferson’s assessment of Islam or the political meaning of El-Sayed’s reference.
DeSantis approached the issue through Jefferson’s later dealings with the Tripoli ambassador. He described Jefferson and Adams meeting the ambassador in London and asking why Muslims were attacking nations that had done them no harm. To support his point, DeSantis cited their letter to John Jay dated March 28, 1786. The distinction in timing matters: the purchase described by historians came before the diplomatic exchange DeSantis highlighted. His response adds evidence about a later encounter, rather than direct evidence of Jefferson’s original reason for buying the book.
What the Ambassador’s Answer Actually Establishes
In the passage DeSantis shared, Jefferson and Adams attributed a religious justification for attacks and enslavement to the ambassador. Their account reads: “The Ambassador [of Tripoli] answered us that it was founded on the Laws of their Prophet, that it was written in their Koran, that all nations who should not have acknowledged their authority were sinners, that it was their right and duty to make war upon them wherever they could be found, and to make slaves of all they could take as Prisoners, and that every Musselman who should be slain in battle was sure to go to Paradise.” Those are the ambassador’s positions as recorded in the letter. They are not statements of Jefferson’s approval. Nor should attribution disappear simply because the passage is politically potent. The account concerns a particular official’s defense of coercion.
Thomas Jefferson and John Adams met the Tripoli Ambassador in London and asked why Muslims were attacking nations who had done them no harm.
In a letter to John Jay dated March 28, 1786, they wrote:
“The Ambassador [of Tripoli] answered us that it was founded on the Laws of… https://t.co/jyblKTqi72
— Ron DeSantis (@RonDeSantis) November 16, 2026
DeSantis also pointed to Jefferson later waging war against the Barbary pirates during his presidency. That history makes his rebuttal more substantial than a bare objection to El-Sayed’s religious choice. Ownership of a religious text does not necessarily imply agreement with its teachings, much less agreement with every political claim made in its name. But the same standard cuts against overstating the rebuttal. Jefferson’s later conflict cannot automatically be treated as the explanation for an earlier purchase. The strongest argument here is for fuller historical context, not a shortcut to Jefferson’s private motives.
David Steinberg welcomed DeSantis’s post and argued that the episode deserved attention in elementary education. Other replies emphasized the Barbary conflict and attacks on captured Americans. Those reactions show how quickly an oath-of-office discussion became an argument about national security and historical memory. They also reflect commentary from individual users, not additional documentation of Jefferson’s thinking. Teaching the episode seriously would require preserving those distinctions. A history lesson loses value when a useful detail becomes a claim broader than the evidence supports.
A Rebuttal Is Stronger When It Stays Precise
Several replies went further, making sweeping claims about Islam, Western civilization and American history. Those statements belong to the people posting them, not to the historical letter DeSantis cited. An account of an ambassador justifying attacks on religious grounds does not establish what every Muslim believes. It also supplies no evidence that El-Sayed endorses that ambassador’s position. Criticism of religiously justified warfare can be direct without collapsing those distinctions. Political arguments become weaker, not tougher, when they substitute collective accusations for evidence about the person under discussion.
El-Sayed’s brief invocation of Jefferson invited scrutiny because a famous owner’s name can carry more rhetorical weight than the underlying fact warrants. DeSantis supplied a consequential part of the historical picture that simple appeals to Jefferson’s library leave out. Still, the exchange does not establish El-Sayed’s intended edition or resolve Jefferson’s original purchasing motive. The fair conclusion is narrower and stronger than the loudest replies suggest. Jefferson owned a Quran, and his later dealings included confronting an ambassador’s religious defense of violence. Neither fact should be used to erase the other.
Source: Twitchy


